Sunday, January 20, 2013

Point & Counterpoint: Protection Vs Encouragement

A few days ago when I went to a local fruit and vegetable chain store called as Kovai Pazhamudir Nilayam, it was a pleasant surprise to see a poster wherein they are attempting to leverage social media network as a marketing initiative. As you can see from this picture, it is a simple database building initiative and incentivizes the customer with a discount coupon.
 
 
 
It is interesting to see how this regional chain is adapting and innovating to create and maintain a competitive advantage. They have approximately 35 plus shops largely in and around Chennai and Coimbatore and predominantly sell fruits and vegetables. Interestingly this is a category which even the larger chains find to be very challenging to manage.

This reminded me of another chain in the pharma space; Pasumai chain of pharmacies. They operate on a franchise model and are again regional with stores largely in Tamil Nadu. They leverage the core concept of Retailing which is aggregation of volumes, thereby creating value.

I am not sure if the coincidence that both these chains are from Coimbatore is an important element given that the region is known for being home to a large number of entrepreneurs.

The larger message pertains to the fact that Indian Retail chains and also stand-alone shop owners have it in them to keep pace and be competitive while also evolving to keep pace with times. Why can’t this spirit of initiative and competiveness be encouraged and enabled by well thought out policies and assistance?

Is it better to assume that these shop owners are an incompetent lot that requires protection from the big ‘bad’ international Retailers or it is more practical and viable to create an enabling environment for these businesses to develop and grow?

In that context I wonder what would have happened if our small and medium manufacturers had been enabled and encouraged to compete on a global scale. Would they have given China a run for their money?

0 comments:

Post a Comment